登陆注册
5589700000005

第5章 INTRODUCTORY(4)

Hence there is a distinction between such a history of a sect as I contemplate and a history of scientific inquiry or of pure philosophy.A history of mathematical or physical science would differ from a direct exposition of the science,but only in so far as it would state truths in the order of discovery,not in the order most convenient for displaying them as a system.It would show what were the processes by which they were originally found out,and how they have been afterwards annexed or absorbed in some wider generalisation.

These facts might be stated without any reference to the history of the discoverers or of the society to which they belonged.They would indeed suggest very interesting topics to the general historian or 'sociologist.'He might be led to inquire under what conditions men came to inquire scientifically at all;why they ceased for centuries to care for science;why they took up special departments of investigation;and what was the effect of scientific discoveries upon social relations in general.But the two inquiries would be distinct for obvious reasons.If men study mathematics they can only come to one conclusion.They will find out the same propositions of geometry if they only think clearly enough and long enough,as certainly as Columbus would discover America if he only sailed far enough.America was there,and so in a sense are the propositions.We may therefore in this case entirely separate the two questions:what leads men to think?and what conclusions will they reach?The reasons which guided the first discoverers are just as valid now,though they can be more systematically stated.But in the 'moral sciences'this distinction is not equally possible.The intellectual and the social evolution are closely and intricately connected,and each reacts upon the other.In the last resort no doubt a definitive system of belief once elaborated would repose upon universally valid truths and determine,instead of being determined by,the corresponding social order.But in the concrete evolution which,we may hope,is approximating towards this result,the creeds current among mankind have been determined by the social conditions as well as helped to determine them.To give an account of that process it is necessary to specify the various circumstances which may lead to the survival of error,and to the partial views of truth taken by men of different idiosyncrasies working upon different data and moved by different passions and prepossessions.

A history written upon these terms would show primarily what,as a fact,were the dominant beliefs during a given period,and state which survived,which disappeared,and which were transformed or engrafted upon other systems of thought.This would of course raise the question of the truth or falsehood of the doctrines as well as of their vitality:for the truth is at least one essential condition of permanent vitality.The difference would be that the problem would be approached from a different side.We should ask first what beliefs have flourished,and afterwards ask why they flourished,and how far their vitality was due to their partial or complete truth.To write such a history would perhaps require an impartiality which few people possess and which I do not venture to claim.I have my own opinions for which other people may account by prejudice,assumption,or downright incapacity.I am quite aware that I shall be implicitly criticising myself in criticising others.All that I can profess is that by taking the questions in this order,I shall hope to fix attention upon one set of considerations which are apt,as I fancy,to be unduly neglected.The result of reading some histories is to raise the question:how people on the other side came to be such unmitigated fools?Why were they imposed upon by such obvious fallacies?That may be answered by considering more fully the conditions under which the opinions were actually adopted,and one result may be to show that those opinions had a considerable element of truth,and were held by men who were the very opposite of fools.At any rate I shall do what I can to write an account of this phase of thought,so as to bring out what were its real tenets;to what intellectual type they were naturally congenial;what were the limitations of view which affected the Utilitarians'conception of the problems to be solved;and what were the passions and prepossessions due to the contemporary state of society and to their own class position,which to some degree unconsciously dictated their conclusions.So far as I can do this satisfactorily,I hope that I may throw some light upon the intrinsic value of the creed,and the place which it should occupy in a definitive system.

NOTES:

1.Table Talk,3July 1830.

同类推荐
  • 侠义风月传

    侠义风月传

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 广百论本

    广百论本

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Tempest

    Tempest

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Of Taxes

    Of Taxes

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 袖中锦

    袖中锦

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 万道唯心

    万道唯心

    在世界的尽头,有无上巨龙在战斗,有绝世强者在厮杀......青山少年,凭借魔王的封印走出大青山,步入强者的世界。在顺境中化身成神,在逆境中化身成魔。
  • 清明无战事

    清明无战事

    本书讲述了这样一个故事:因协助美国教会转移战争孤儿,安如玉、夏樱桃、唐小顺和美国传教士保罗被日寇抓捕。唐家山开明乡绅唐汉宸,严正拒绝日寇的交涉条件,被俘人员惨遭侮辱杀害。反扫荡作战,我方缴获了日方成百盒骨灰。唐汉宸道义高标,力排众议,主导归还日方骨灰,迎回我方人员遗体,时间定在清明节,并约定这一天不起战事。不料日寇背信弃义,唐汉宸身背“抗日分子”的亡命旗坦然赴死。本书所要彰显的是,与日寇的言而无信相比,唐汉宸身上所葆有的华夏文明,形成了对日本军国主义法西斯的殊死抵抗——仁者无敌。
  • Catherine

    Catherine

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 审美价值结构与情感逻辑

    审美价值结构与情感逻辑

    本书是孙绍振教授文艺学理论研究部分成果的结集。孙先生1960年毕业于北京大学,既沐浴了五四文化重镇诸多学术大师的思想余泽,又得到当时云集北大的朱光潜、蔡仪、金岳霖等各具代表性的哲学、美学、语言、文学大家的学术熏陶与逻辑训练,而十几年僵化的庸俗社会学的教条则孕育了他的怀疑与批判精神。
  • 谋杀FM103

    谋杀FM103

    夜比墨汁还黑。前车灯射出两道剑状光芒,截截劈开弯弯曲曲的山道。女记者刘琦坐在副驾驶座上,紧系安全带,两手撑住警车前身,用力保持平稳。刑侦科科长高毅紧握方向盘,两眼发红,眼球突出,已经差不多进入癫狂状态。是的,他们在飚车,但不是为了潇洒,而是追赶一辆红色法拉利。地点:城郊西山。山道弯多,路陡。在黑夜中闯山道很刺激。不过,这样的刺激让人吃不消。眼见那辆法拉利已经奔向山顶,那是绝径,无路可逃。山下看上去黑黢黢一片虚空,隐藏着五百里茫茫滇池。一片灯海在很远的东北方若隐若现。
  • 王妃改嫁豪门总裁:穿越成婚

    王妃改嫁豪门总裁:穿越成婚

    豪门总裁不小心穿越而来,面对自己的主子帅总裁嚎叫道:“我可是个上市公司的总裁!我在2016可是个了不起的人物!”准王妃甚是鄙夷:“你现在就是一个身无分文不知来历的穷小厮,还是老老实实的呆在宰相府中好生给我做事吧。古时代的准王妃为爱穿越,可是面对昔日的爱人却不认得自己时,她含泪委屈:“我可是燕倾国的宰相千金,当朝的准王妃!那是一个属于我们柳家的朝代!”总裁傲慢的冷笑道:“你现在就只是我的女佣,走出我的家门你就是一个连身份证都没有的黑户!会被人贩抓去卖掉的,还是乖乖的呆在我的身边伺候我吧。”
  • 败家系统在花都

    败家系统在花都

    起点首发新书《当首富只是我的副业》已发布。这次老风没幺蛾子了!主持人:您的梦想是什么?吕小布:混吃等死,为所欲为。主持人:既然如此,那您是怎么成为全球首富的?吕小布:我特么哪知道?你问败家子怎么赚钱?真的是!我要回去睡觉了。主持人:别……吕小布:赏,五千。主持人:跪送小布少爷,小布少爷千秋万代,一统江湖!吕小布:哇咔咔!
  • 重生康熙王朝之我是废太子

    重生康熙王朝之我是废太子

    回家给老东西过六十大寿,救了个女的。救就救吧,咱挨撞了。撞就撞吧,还重生了。重生就重生吧,还是个废太子。叫我如何是好?
  • 繁星灿絮尽

    繁星灿絮尽

    我一直以为真正的世界就是我所存在的世界。在这个世界上渺小的我会努力拼搏,会百折不挠,但是我终究是平凡的。如果哪天我真的死去了,就像大海少了一滴水,无波无涟。事实告诉我,不要妄自菲薄,不要轻视自己的重要性。也许你就像那蝴蝶,历史的走向也许就是因为你。
  • THE FIGURE IN THE CARPET

    THE FIGURE IN THE CARPET

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。