登陆注册
5448400000018

第18章

disciples, and whether this may not be that famous art of rhetoric which Thrasymachus and others teach and practise? Skilful speakers they are, and impart their skill to any who is willing to make kings of them and to bring gifts to them.

Phaedr.Yes, they are royal men; but their art is not the same with the art of those whom you call, and rightly, in my opinion, dialecticians:-Still we are in the dark about rhetoric.

Soc.What do you mean? The remains of it, if there be anything remaining which can be brought under rules of art, must be a fine thing; and, at any rate, is not to be despised by you and me.But how much is left?

Phaedr.There is a great deal surely to be found in books of rhetoric?

Soc.Yes; thank you for reminding me:-There is the exordium, showing how the speech should begin, if I remember rightly; that is what you mean-the niceties of the art?

Phaedr.Yes.

Soc.Then follows the statement of facts, and upon that witnesses;thirdly, proofs; fourthly, probabilities are to come; the great Byzantian word-maker also speaks, if I am not mistaken, of confirmation and further confirmation.

Phaedr.You mean the excellent Theodorus.

Soc.Yes; and he tells how refutation or further refutation is to be managed, whether in accusation or defence.I ought also to mention the illustrious Parian, Evenus, who first invented insinuations and indirect praises; and also indirect censures, which according to some he put into verse to help the memory.But shall I "to dumb forgetfulness consign" Tisias and Gorgias, who are not ignorant that probability is superior to truth, and who by: force of argument make the little appear great and the great little, disguise the new in old fashions and the old in new fashions, and have discovered forms for everything, either short or going on to infinity.I remember Prodicus laughing when I told him of this; he said that he had himself discovered the true rule of art, which was to be neither long nor short, but of a convenient length.

Phaedr.Well done, Prodicus!

Soc.Then there is Hippias the Elean stranger, who probably agrees with him.

Phaedr.Yes.

Soc.And there is also Polus, who has treasuries of diplasiology, and gnomology, and eikonology, and who teaches in them the names of which Licymnius made him a present; they were to give a polish.

Phaedr.Had not Protagoras something of the same sort?

Soc.Yes, rules of correct diction and many other fine precepts; for the "sorrows of a poor old man," or any other pathetic case, no one is better than the Chalcedonian giant; he can put a whole company of people into a passion and out of one again by his mighty magic, and is first-rate at inventing or disposing of any sort of calumny on any grounds or none.All of them agree in asserting that a speech should end in a recapitulation, though they do not all agree to use the same word.

Phaedr.You mean that there should be a summing up of the arguments in order to remind the hearers of them.

Soc.I have now said all that I have to say of the art of rhetoric: have you anything to add?

Phaedr.Not much; nothing very important.

Soc.Leave the unimportant and let us bring the really important question into the light of day, which is: What power has this art of rhetoric, and when?

Phaedr.A very great power in public meetings.

Soc.It has.But I should like to know whether you have the same feeling as I have about the rhetoricians? To me there seem to be a great many holes in their web.

Phaedr.Give an example.

Soc.I will.Suppose a person to come to your friend Eryximachus, or to his father Acumenus, and to say to him: "I know how to apply drugs which shall have either a heating or a cooling effect, and I can give a vomit and also a purge, and all that sort of thing; and knowing all this, as I do, I claim to be a physician and to make physicians by imparting this knowledge to others,"-what do you suppose that they would say?

Phaedr.They would be sure to ask him whether he knew "to whom" he would give his medicines, and "when," and "how much."Soc.And suppose that he were to reply: "No; I know nothing of all that; I expect the patient who consults me to be able to do these things for himself"?

Phaedr.They would say in reply that he is a madman or pedant who fancies that he is a physician because he has read something in a book, or has stumbled on a prescription or two, although he has no real understanding of the art of medicine.

Soc.And suppose a person were to come to Sophocles or Euripides and say that he knows how to make a very long speech about a small matter, and a short speech about a great matter, and also a sorrowful speech, or a terrible, or threatening speech, or any other kind of speech, and in teaching this fancies that he is teaching the art of tragedy-?

Phaedr.They too would surely laugh at him if he fancies that tragedy is anything but the arranging of these elements in a manner which will be suitable to one another and to the whole.

Soc.But I do not suppose that they would be rude or abusive to him:

Would they not treat him as a musician would a man who thinks that he is a harmonist because he knows how to pitch the highest and lowest notes; happening to meet such an one he would not say to him savagely, "Fool, you are mad!" But like a musician, in a gentle and harmonious tone of voice, he would answer: "My good friend, he who would be a harmonist must certainly know this, and yet he may understand nothing of harmony if he has not got beyond your stage of knowledge, for you only know the preliminaries of harmony and not harmony itself."Phaedr.Very true.

Soc.And will not Sophocles say to the display of the would-be tragedian, that this is not tragedy but the preliminaries of tragedy? and will not Acumenus say the same of medicine to the would-be physician?

Phaedr.Quite true.

同类推荐
  • 中藏经

    中藏经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 续医说

    续医说

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 明伦汇编官常典县佐部

    明伦汇编官常典县佐部

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 禅林备用清规

    禅林备用清规

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 慈氏菩萨略修愈誐念诵法

    慈氏菩萨略修愈誐念诵法

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 快穿:女神不女配

    快穿:女神不女配

    秦步摇死了,身为朝华公主可笑又可悲的一生竟是成为了他人的垫脚石。她就是她,她的人生自然是自己说了算,凭什么要去做别人的配角?遇上一个神秘的系统,从此开启时空穿越之旅。拯救那些因为各种原因跌入泥泞,成为他人配角的女神们,让她们的人生焕发出本有的荣光!可是……那个男人,那个说会永远陪着她的男人,那个一次又一次出现在她身边的男人,那个一次又一次被她忘记的男人,那个一次又一次说爱她的男人……你是谁?本文1V1。
  • 创世进化录

    创世进化录

    当地球变成游戏的世界,当所有人变成游戏的玩家。黑暗的纪元里,活着已是一种奢望,冥冥命运中,每个人都是受神明支配,供其娱乐的棋子。秦飞为逃脱命运的支配,誓要跳出棋局外,成为界外执棋者,成神的路注定不平凡!高高在上的众神们!真的以为你们的神位可以永恒吗?
  • 光影交错之旅

    光影交错之旅

    古老的神袛将走出神国,深渊的魔鬼己降临世间。异界的灵魂不甘心平凡,新的诸王誓为权柄而战。血脉的传承令龙翼蔽空,迷茫的行者踏上求真之路。
  • 征途

    征途

    上古,一场横扫诸界的旷世之战爆发,三界尽毁,天国坠落,参战各族传承断绝,损失惨重,史称浩劫之战。战后人族虽迅速壮大,但因人皇陨落,致人族长期兴而不旺,分化十国百派,更有万族掺和,数千年来征战不休。千年之后,浩劫之战的端倪再现,灭世之火重新点燃。且看身负妖皇血脉的穿越者天佑,如何隐于仙门之内,以现代眼光造战车、铸傀儡,收妖王于帐下,揽美人在身侧?如何克服入道过晚的困难,从零开始,打破阴阳、解析术法,铸一身混元道体,搏一次五行同修?“来吧,诸位战士、法师、道士、医仙……加入我的征途,终结战的时代!”
  • 鸾倾宫之如妃当道

    鸾倾宫之如妃当道

    一朝为妃,宫中权势瞬间倾倒。恩宠于身,傲然新旧容颜更替。如玥满心以为,这是她入宫以来最好的时候。大权在手,能与皇后分庭抗礼。恩宠不减,即便新人娇艳,可皇上的心始终怜惜自己。岂料小公主的夭折,再度掀起后宫里血雨腥风的争斗。刺骨的伤痛背后,竟然是蓄谋已久的杀害!
  • 元曲三百首

    元曲三百首

    《古典诗词精品丛书·元曲三百首》收录了三百首元曲精品诗词供文学爱好者赏析。中国古典文学发展到元代出现了又一座丰碑,这就是我们常说的“元曲”。清末王国维在《宋元戏曲考序》中说:“凡一代有一代之文学:楚之骚,汉之赋,六代之骈语,唐之诗,宋之词,元之曲,皆所谓一代之文学,而后世莫能继焉者也。”这就充分肯定了元散曲在诗歌史上的地位。
  • 平凡至尊

    平凡至尊

    他名平凡,但绝不甘于平凡,一起来看看平凡至尊不平凡之路。龙扬报得大仇后,晴雨为再次封印欧阳无道,不得不以再次沉睡为代价,施展禁术。龙扬为救师尊不得不踏上至尊之路。成为平凡至尊,挽救苍生。愿一生只爱你一人足以,天道无情,我便灭天,若有人欺负你,我便杀他,若天下人欺负你,我便屠尽天下人。
  • 剑和远方

    剑和远方

    有人问我为什么去冒险,我说是因为对自由的向往和冒险的热爱。可当夜深人静的时候,自己才知道都是瞎扯。离开,仅仅只是因为骗不了自己,一路的旅行,最容易麻痹心灵,忘却过去。也许当我年老的时候,会再回到那个地方,写一本小说,好好讲一讲自己的故事。
  • 鼓之舞(中国好小说)

    鼓之舞(中国好小说)

    小说的明线是讲述一支城市锣鼓队在艰难生存中获得成功。作为主人公的敏枝和她的小姑子叶枚围绕锣鼓队的指挥发生了很多故事。另一条线索,是敏枝的情感纠葛。她怀念着抛她而去的诗人,对处处照顾她的队长心生好感,而自己的有些猥琐的丈夫,却让她无所适从。随着丈夫叶涛的离去,她的感情似乎也获得了新生。
  • 狂妃嫁到,世子笑一个

    狂妃嫁到,世子笑一个

    本文女主智商在线走甜宠路线不喜勿喷欢迎加收藏多多评论哦暗夜神偷一朝穿越,只为在这乱世守护家人安稳,再撩些帅哥完了自己上辈子的心愿。不料向往的慢慢撩汉路竟然被这个行动派的世子半路拦截,好吧既然是你先勾引我的,你就要负责哦。什么?我家富可敌国,不不不我还要更多的金子什么?那白莲花竟然又来捞便宜,还不给我打出去什么?世子已经求得婚书,快藏起我的那些情书别被发现了某天没爹疼没娘爱的神偷终于打算洗手不干时,华丽丽的穿越了好吧,此处也甚好,鸟语花香,金子不少,还有眼前萌萌哒的小正太,,,,