登陆注册
5369800000043

第43章

Error of Mr Godwin is considering man too much in the light of a being merely rational - In the compound being, man, the passions will always act as disturbing forces in the decisions of the understanding - Reasonings of Mr Godwin on the subject of coercion - Some truths of a nature not to be communicated from one man to another.

IN the chapter which I have been examining, Mr Godwin professes to consider the objection to his system of equality from the principle of population. It has appeared, I think clearly, that he is greatly erroneous in his statement of the distance of this difficulty, and that instead of myriads of centuries, it is really not thirty years, or even thirty days, distant from us.

The supposition of the approach of man to immortality on earth is certainly not of a kind to soften the difficulty. The only argument, therefore, in the chapter which has any tendency to remove the objection is the conjecture concerning the extinction of the passion between the sexes, but as this is a mere conjecture, unsupported by the smallest shadow of proof, the force of the objection may be fairly said to remain unimpaired, and it is undoubtedly of sufficient weight of itself completely to overturn Mr Godwin's whole system of equality. I will, however, make one or two observations on a few of the prominent parts of Mr Godwin's reasonings which will contribute to place in a still clearer point of view the little hope that we can reasonably entertain of those vast improvements in the nature of man and of society which he holds up to our admiring gaze in his Political Justice.

Mr Godwin considers man too much in the light of a being merely intellectual. This error, at least such I conceive it to be, pervades his whole work and mixes itself with all his reasonings. The voluntary actions of men may originate in their opinions, but these opinions will be very differently modified in creatures compounded of a rational faculty and corporal propensities from what they would be in beings wholly intellectual. Mr Godwin, in proving that sound reasoning and truth are capable of being adequately communicated, examines the proposition first practically, and then adds, 'Such is the appearance which this proposition assumes, when examined in a loose and practical view. In strict consideration it will not admit of debate. Man is a rational being, etc.' (Bk. I, ch. 5; in the third edition Vol. I, p. 88). So far from calling this a strict consideration of the subject, I own I should call it the loosest, and most erroneous, way possible, of considering it. It is the calculating the velocity of a falling body in vacuo, and persisting in it, that it would be the same through whatever resisting mediums it might fall. This was not Newton's mode of philosophizing. Very few general propositions are just in application to a particular subject. The moon is not kept in her orbit round the earth, nor the earth in her orbit round the sun, by a force that varies merely in the inverse ratio of the squares of the distances. To make the general theory just in application to the revolutions of these bodies, it was necessary to calculate accurately the disturbing force of the sun upon the moon, and of the moon upon the earth; and till these disturbing forces were properly estimated, actual observations on the motions of these bodies would have proved that the theory was not accurately true.

I am willing to allow that every voluntary act is preceded by a decision of the mind, but it is strangely opposite to what Ishould conceive to be the just theory upon the subject, and a palpable contradiction to all experience, to say that the corporal propensities of man do not act very powerfully, as disturbing forces, in these decisions. The question, therefore, does not merely depend upon whether a man may be made to understand a distinct proposition or be convinced by an unanswerable argument. A truth may be brought home to his conviction as a rational being, though he may determine to act contrary to it, as a compound being. The cravings of hunger, the love of liquor, the desire of possessing a beautiful woman, will urge men to actions, of the fatal consequences of which, to the general interests of society, they are perfectly well convinced, even at the very time they commit them. Remove their bodily cravings, and they would not hesitate a moment in determining against such actions. Ask them their opinion of the same conduct in another person, and they would immediately reprobate it. But in their own case, and under all the circumstances of their situation with these bodily cravings, the decision of the compound being is different from the conviction of the rational being.

If this be the just view of the subject, and both theory and experience unite to prove that it is, almost all Mr Godwin's reasonings on the subject of coercion in his seventh chapter, will appear to be founded on error. He spends some time in placing in a ridiculous point of view the attempt to convince a man's understanding and to clear up a doubtful proposition in his mind, by blows. Undoubtedly it is both ridiculous and barbarous, and so is cock-fighting, but one has little more to do with the real object of human punishments than the other. One frequent (indeed much too frequent) mode of punishment is death. Mr Godwin will hardly think this intended for conviction, at least it does not appear how the individual or the society could reap much future benefit from an understanding enlightened in this manner.

同类推荐
  • 永乐大典残卷

    永乐大典残卷

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 晋阳秋

    晋阳秋

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 太上开明天地本真经

    太上开明天地本真经

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 汲冢纪年存真

    汲冢纪年存真

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 戒单

    戒单

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 培养最优秀的男孩

    培养最优秀的男孩

    父母的威信是对孩子进行有效教育和孩子自觉接受父母教育的前提条件和重要保证。加强对自己的智力投资,注重提高自身素质,有助于维护并提高父母在子女心目中的威信,男孩尤需要父母对其世界进行扩充和引导。如果你在他面前老是一问三不知,尽管表面上孩子仍然怕你,而实际上你在孩子心目中的威信已经渐渐地丧失了。教子箴言:教育孩子如育花,精心浇水、施肥、呵护,方能成功。但事实上并不是所有人都能养好花,不懂得就要向别人请教,学习养花的经验与艺术。
  • 狄公案

    狄公案

    《狄公案》抨击了权势豪强对百姓的欺凌,歌颂了江湖豪侠的侠义行为。故事情节跌宕曲折,极富传奇色彩。文辞也通俗流畅,生动风趣,具有民间文学韵味。人物刻画细腻传神,如鲍自安的老练诙谐、武功超群,花振芳的豪爽耿直、敢作敢为,义仆余谦的疾恶如仇,鲍金花的骄矜好胜,花碧莲的质朴情挚,都个性鲜明。
  • 暴躁校花:小子你别跑!

    暴躁校花:小子你别跑!

    一群小逗逼的纯纯爱情故事:表面清纯内心暴躁的绝美校花,艺术天份极高的帅气小混混,三个身高超过1米8的宠妹狂魔哥哥
  • 习道中人

    习道中人

    他活在世界的意义是什么……
  • 末世美食屋

    末世美食屋

    或许我这里将是这末世最后一片净土,一片充满香气的净土。
  • 迷彩军营

    迷彩军营

    又过了两天,很多昔日的“战友”都轻轻松松地出来,可以痛痛快快地哭笑,痛痛快快地咒骂了。干警们给每人都发了路费,还说了许多安慰的话,让大家先回家去,三个月之内不要外出活动,随时听候公安机关的进一步询问调查,希望大家继续配合。大家感激,说这几个月好像做了一场梦,恶梦,可得在家好好调养些日子了。一朝遭蛇咬,十年怕井绳,还没脸啊?哪儿也不去了,放心吧。
  • 议兵

    议兵

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 甜妻来袭:萧少,走着瞧

    甜妻来袭:萧少,走着瞧

    【民国甜宠+女主外星人+伪兄妹】萧大帅追妻有三招:卖腐,自恋加硬撩。(一)古里芃芃:“萧熠然,别碰我男神,把你的爪从他身上拿下来!”萧大帅邪魅一笑,“好,不碰他,我碰你!”众人:大帅,放下你妹妹,让我们来!(二)古里芃芃:“我对灯发四,一定会砍了萧熠然的桃花,让他当万年单身狗!”萧大帅闻言眉开眼笑:“果然,本帅是民国第一美,小狐狸也为我的美貌所倾倒,怕我招蜂引蝶,她真是爱惨了我!”众人:大帅,你怕不是想多了!(三)古里芃芃将自己裹成大粽子,“萧熠然,别过来!”“纯情”大帅不紧不慢地解开衬衣扣子,“不想吃肉吗?肉很好吃!我也是第一次吃,我们一起研究!”众人:这样我们男配就没戏了?不阔能!
  • 李云龙戏民国

    李云龙戏民国

    总想一朝穿越,事事料敌于前,纸上谈兵终觉浅,成事千阻万难;携兄弟三千,欲竟全功于此间,枕戈以待二十年,吾必死在今天!
  • 一幽一默,人生无难事(中文版)

    一幽一默,人生无难事(中文版)

    幽默,几乎是一个永恒的话题,生活离不开幽默。幽默可以使你在出现错误时被人所谅解,可以使你在众人之中被亲切地接受和认同,可以使你的公司形象不败,可以使你的商品轻易地进入顾客的购物袋,可以使你找到欢乐同享患难与共的合作伙伴。特别是在人生纷至而来的困惑中,它会帮你化被动为主动,以轻松的微笑代替沉重的叹息。