登陆注册
5270400000106

第106章

The best way to secure training and practice in arguments of this kind is in the first place to get into the habit of converting the arguments. For in this way we shall be better equipped for dealing with the proposition stated, and after a few attempts we shall know several arguments by heart. For by 'conversion' of an argument is meant the taking the reverse of the conclusion together with the remaining propositions asked and so demolishing one of those that were conceded: for it follows necessarily that if the conclusion be untrue, some one of the premisses is demolished, seeing that, given all the premisses, the conclusion was bound to follow. Always, in dealing with any proposition, be on the look-out for a line of argument both pro and con: and on discovering it at once set about looking for the solution of it: for in this way you will soon find that you have trained yourself at the same time in both asking questions and answering them. If we cannot find any one else to argue with, we should argue with ourselves. Select, moreover, arguments relating to the same thesis and range them side by side: for this produces a plentiful supply of arguments for carrying a point by sheer force, and in refutation also it is of great service, whenever one is well stocked with arguments pro and con: for then you find yourself on your guard against contrary statements to the one you wish to secure.

Moreover, as contributing to knowledge and to philosophic wisdom the power of discerning and holding in one view the results of either of two hypotheses is no mean instrument; for it then only remains to make a right choice of one of them. For a task of this kind a certain natural ability is required: in fact real natural ability just is the power right to choose the true and shun the false. Men of natural ability can do this; for by a right liking or disliking for whatever is proposed to them they rightly select what is best.

It is best to know by heart arguments upon those questions which are of most frequent occurrence, and particularly in regard to those propositions which are ultimate: for in discussing these answerers frequently give up in despair. Moreover, get a good stock of definitions: and have those of familiar and primary ideas at your fingers' ends: for it is through these that reasonings are effected.

You should try, moreover, to master the heads under which other arguments mostly tend to fall. For just as in geometry it is useful to be practised in the elements, and in arithmetic to have the multiplication table up to ten at one's fingers' ends-and indeed it makes a great difference in one's knowledge of the multiples of other numbers too-likewise also in arguments it is a great advantage to be well up in regard to first principles, and to have a thorough knowledge of premisses at the tip of one's tongue. For just as in a person with a trained memory, a memory of things themselves is immediately caused by the mere mention of their loci, so these habits too will make a man readier in reasoning, because he has his premisses classified before his mind's eye, each under its number.

同类推荐
  • 君子堂日询手镜

    君子堂日询手镜

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 達海叢書·附錄

    達海叢書·附錄

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 说矩里迦龙王像法

    说矩里迦龙王像法

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 帝京岁时纪胜

    帝京岁时纪胜

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Mansfield Park

    Mansfield Park

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 呆侠成神记

    呆侠成神记

    人生如梦,昏昏沉沉。多少年蹉跎云烟。秋叶凋零不是昨日那青春少年。梦醒,问花开是否依然芬芳美艳?却涌流满腹深仇念。
  • 万水千山总有情

    万水千山总有情

    北京,一个从孤儿院被收养的女孩叶雅雯与其养父感情甚深,外表看似纤弱,却因为骨子里的倔强和言语上的不饶人收获了自己的事业与爱情。一个阴差阳错与另一个女孩结怨后,牵扯出来二代人的爱恨纠葛,使得她原本的生活,不再平静。
  • 鬼帝宠妻

    鬼帝宠妻

    【一对一独宠】青素,北大经济学研究生,当界大学生散打冠军,路见不平拔刀相助,挂了……童颜,北宁王府嫡出小姐,刚入宫门封三品昭仪,不幸皇帝纵欲过度,殁了……青素醒来发现似乎死错了地方,她变成了被逼殉葬的亡妃‘童颜’。于是,第一次见面是这样的。在刚驾崩的皇帝陵墓中……他是已故先皇,活着的。她是殉葬亡妃,穿越的。她淡定地看着‘先帝’一双纤长玉手正在解开她的衣裳。嗯?这是要奸尸的情况?“先帝,我还是活的。”她忍着想一拳打扁那张妖孽般脸的冲动,冷冷道。‘先帝’一脸正经,“哦……这儿风光无限好,幽静而无人打扰,朕想起还没与爱妃圆房呢。”缓缓俯下身子,俊美无双的脸近在咫尺,“此处可好?朕的殉葬王妃。”“……”很好很好,的确无人,都是死鬼!为了活命她与伪鬼帝达成合作协议……古语云,有钱能使鬼推磨。斗斗王爷,翻翻皇陵,收收古玩,卖卖鬼帝,放放高利贷,就这样随便干点啥,省得无聊。待她傲立万里河山之巅,倾国倾城伪鬼帝摇着羽扇悠悠然,“老婆,可满意夫君一路保驾护航,助你纵横天下,颠覆皇权,挣得你这一生潋滟风华,璀璨无悔?”【魂魂PS:有夫如君,夫复何求】
  • 文娱的良心

    文娱的良心

    有人说,他是文娱界的良心。说这话的人,你的良心不会痛吗?……很多年以后,人们不记得十一的挖坑不填、死女主、死男主……人们只记得他那颗善良的心。——————PS:此文有毒,主角有病,病得不轻,报复心极重,娱乐而已,不必较真……书友群203384119。
  • 逆命战歌

    逆命战歌

    天使是要带给世人幸福的,但在那之前要先尝尽世间所有痛苦,所有。——新·新圣约选自嘉米勒·希斯博尔教皇语录
  • 深林晴时雨

    深林晴时雨

    林深。十八岁,我走在你前面茫然前进,殊不知你的用心。十九岁,我终不再徘徊,却发现你已不在。二十岁,我已习惯一切,看透世间尘埃,却没料到你突然的出现。二十一岁,我始终孤身一人,一个雨天,我被送了一把伞,我知道那是你,但是你却仓皇而逃。郑宇聪,十八岁,我走在你身后看你跌跟斗,想帮忙却开不了口。十九岁,我深知你已长大,原谅我一声不响的离开。二十岁,我终于成为了自己,不知道你是否在期盼我的归来。二十一岁,我始终在你身边,你却看不见。一个雨天,我送了你一把伞,我没有太大勇气,原谅我的仓皇而逃。我在等雨停也在等你。
  • 弱女子十年不屈洗冤路

    弱女子十年不屈洗冤路

    妹妹自杀,患有精神疾病的妹夫被认定为杀妻凶手。当警察的姐姐宋淑杰发现此案疑点重重,漏洞百出,是一起冤案。为了给妹夫洗冤,她坚持上访告状12年,写下申诉信1万封,150多万字,上访800余次,历尽艰辛,终于使妹夫无罪释放,重见天日,上演了一出当代版的杨三姐告状。警察宋淑杰的告状历程一波三折,揭示出的司法腐败问题令人震惊。《杨三姐告状》是我国评剧舞台上久演不衰的剧目。民国七年,民女杨三姐为了给死去的姐姐申冤,赴县衙告状。县官受贿,贪赃枉法,竟判凶手赔款了结。杨三姐不服判决,又赴天津高等检察厅上告。新任厅长秉公执法,查明了真相,将凶手法办处决。
  • 噬灵武帝

    噬灵武帝

    灵云大陆以武为尊,南宫家族少爷南宫天直至十五岁未能觉醒武灵,受尽世人嘲笑欺辱。待到十六岁,他双灵觉醒,抬头对天道:“我命由我不由天,天若逆我,我便吞天。”(因为作者之前一直写仙侠,所以刚开始会有一点仙侠味,后面就不会了。)喜欢的可以加入qq群:930448109
  • 90后剩女

    90后剩女

    长篇小说《90后剩女》从不同的角度不同的时间不同的经历,讲述一个感人肺腑爱情故事,故事描述的是一位90后少女阿美的生活学习和恋爱经历,阿美是一位高中女生,生在农村,因为自己的特长,她被一所大学录取了,从此在花花绿绿的大都市,她开始了她的学习生活。偶然的一个机会,她遇到了一位男孩,后来慢慢地爱上了他……就这样,他几乎改变了她的命运,她的爱情观、价值观、人生观都在这座繁华的城市发生了巨大的变化,阿美将何去何从?小说情节跌宕起伏,一波三折,耐人寻味。有评论家看过此书稿,给予了很高的评价:“它不单纯是一部文学作品,它是一部社会学,尤其是对青少年了解现实社会可起到推波助澜的作用。”
  • 论语:玩诵本

    论语:玩诵本

    《论语》是记录孔子及其弟子言行的一部书,是儒家最重要的一部经典著作。其编纂者是孔子的弟子和再传弟子。所记录的内容很广,涉及哲学、道德、政治、教育、时事、生活、历史、人物等方面,是研究孔子生平和思想的主要依据,南宋朱子(熹)将其列为“四书”之一。《论语》是一部语录体著作,大部分记言,小部分记事,全书20篇,约15000字。篇与篇、章与章之间隐含着一定的内在联系,篇名取每篇开头的两三个字而定。全书经过后世儒者的编订整理,在东汉末年定型。