登陆注册
5231800000040

第40章 SPEECH ON THE POWERS OF JURIES IN PROSECUTIONS FOR

From this principle has risen an opinion that I find current amongst gentlemen, that this distemper ought to be left to cure itself; that the judges having been well exposed, and something terrified on account of these clamours, will entirely change, if not very much relax from their rigour; if the present race should not change, that the chances of succession may put other more constitutional judges in their place; lastly, if neither should happen, yet that the spirit of an English jury will always be sufficient for the vindication of its own rights, and will not suffer itself to be overborne by the bench. I confess that I totally dissent from all these opinions. These suppositions become the strongest reasons with me to evince the necessity of some clear and positive settlement of this question of contested jurisdiction. If judges are so full of levity, so full of timidity, if they are influenced by such mean and unworthy passions, that a popular clamour is sufficient to shake the resolution they build upon the solid basis of a legal principle, I would endeavour to fix that mercury by a positive law. If to please an administration the judges can go one way to-day, and to please the crowd they can go another to-morrow; if they will oscillate backward and forward between power and popularity, it is high time to fix the law in such a manner as to resemble, as it ought, the great Author of all law, in "whom there is no variableness nor shadow of turning."

As to their succession, I have just the same opinion. I would not leave it to the chances of promotion, or to the characters of lawyers, what the law of the land, what the rights of juries, or what the liberty of the press should be. My law should not depend upon the fluctuation of the closet, or the complexion of men.

Whether a black-haired man or a fair-haired man presided in the Court of King's Bench, I would have the law the same: the same whether he was born in domo regnatrice, and sucked from his infancy the milk of courts, or was nurtured in the rugged discipline of a popular opposition. This law of court cabal and of party, this mens quaedam nullo perturbata affectu, this law of complexion, ought not to be endured for a moment in a country whose being depends upon the certainty, clearness, and stability of institutions.

Now I come to the last substitute for the proposed bill, the spirit of juries operating their own jurisdiction. This, I confess, I think the worst of all, for the same reasons on which I objected to the others, and for other weighty reasons besides which are separate and distinct. First, because juries, being taken at random out of a mass of men infinitely large, must be of characters as various as the body they arise from is large in its extent. If the judges differ in their complexions, much more will a jury. A timid jury will give way to an awful judge delivering oracularly the law, and charging them on their oaths, and putting it home to their consciences, to beware of judging where the law had given them no competence. We know that they will do so, they have done so in a hundred instances; a respectable member of your own house, no vulgar man, tells you that on the authority of a judge he found a man guilty, in whom, at the same time, he could find no guilt. But supposing them full of knowledge and full of manly confidence in themselves, how will their knowledge, or their confidence, inform or inspirit others? They give no reason for their verdict, they can but condemn or acquit; and no man can tell the motives on which they have acquitted or condemned. So that this hope of the power of juries to assert their own jurisdiction must be a principle blind, as being without reason, and as changeable as the complexion of men and the temper of the times.

But, after all, is it fit that this dishonourable contention between the court and juries should subsist any longer? On what principle is it that a jury refuses to be directed by the court as to his competence? Whether a libel or no libel be a question of law or of fact may be doubted, but a question of jurisdiction and competence is certainly a question of law; on this the court ought undoubtedly to judge, and to judge solely and exclusively. If they judge wrong from excusable error, you ought to correct it, as to-day it is proposed, by an explanatory bill; or if by corruption, by bill of penalties declaratory, and by punishment. What does a juror say to a judge when he refuses his opinion upon a question of judicature?

同类推荐
  • 跌打秘方

    跌打秘方

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 永乐大典残卷

    永乐大典残卷

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • King John

    King John

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • Renascence and Other Poems

    Renascence and Other Poems

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
  • 宋四家词选目录序论

    宋四家词选目录序论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。汇聚授权电子版权。
热门推荐
  • 贤夫请进

    贤夫请进

    (超爱《天降贤淑男》虽然完结了,但是我还是想把后续写一写。)“你们东女族的男子在未婚前不都是以清白为重吗?所以说,你要以后不许睡在我身边。”某女的神态很认真。某男听到这句话只是打个哈欠翻个身,“不是东女族的女子不都是以清白为重吗?我一直睡在你身旁,所以说要对你负责。不能离开。”听见季澈洵这么回答,顾念念忍不住笑了,锤他胸口,“你好坏。”“彼此彼此。”
  • 最后一个道士3

    最后一个道士3

    查文斌,凌正阳二十七代传人,茅山天正道掌门,一个因救人触犯了天罚的道士,一个源自生活的人物原型。将带领我们走进一个未知的全新的道家世界,重新打开属于传说中的真实腹地。青衣人,忘川渡人,棺中人,为何都与他有着一致的面孔?师傅、父母、儿女为何一个个都会离他而去?卓雄和大山的身世,血色的纹身究竟象征着什么?一切之前的所有谜团将会在《最后一个道士3》全部揭晓!
  • 海洋战国策:邵永灵论海洋大国崛起

    海洋战国策:邵永灵论海洋大国崛起

    海洋在中国一直是一个高烧不退的热门话题。对国人来说,这当中既有欣喜和期待,同时也混杂了忧虑和危机。这种喜忧参半的形势迫使我们开始思考一系列与海洋相关的问题;海洋对我们到底意味着什么?国家的崛起和强盛是否一定需要强大的海权?我们怎么才能抓住海洋带来的机遇并从容应对挑战?在21世纪,中国能成为海军强国吗?本书就是在这一背景下动笔并完成的。书中既有历史又有现实,涉及海洋的属性、海权的历史、强国的兴衰、海军发展战略、海战武器装备、岛屿海域争端等等内容,以期为读者提供一个了解海洋问题的全方位视角。
  • 手可摘星辰:你是我的

    手可摘星辰:你是我的

    活力少女vs腹黑校草教室内_啊啊啊~快看是林少。“同学,今天的作业~”林星辰邪魅一笑。一旁的女孩眼睛直直的看着某男,一边拿名单,视线还不忘盯着林星辰,生怕错过他的一颦一笑。看见名单上那一条黑色的对号,某男勾唇,眨了眨那双撩人的桃花眼,满教室的尖叫声~这一幕被某女看到。“老师来了,老师来了~”苏百可突然站起身,“报告老师,林星辰没写作业还色诱女同学!”“苏百可!”林星辰腾的站起身。老师听后脸色一变“林星辰下课来我办公室一趟!”~~~~~~~~~~八字不合,还能恋爱?
  • 打动人心的100个社交技巧

    打动人心的100个社交技巧

    成功的人生是从良好的人际关系开始的,一个人不可能孤家寡人地活着,也不可能自我封闭起来万事不求人。在正常的人际交往中,为了提高交际效率,应该掌握一些交际技巧,这对每个人的交际都有一定的帮助。本书全方位地介绍了公关办事的方法与技巧:注重形象,好事多磨,因势利导,因人而异,远离禁忌,等等。读者心中的疑惑,几乎都能够在本书中找到答案。
  • 婚后三十六个月

    婚后三十六个月

    当“七年之痒”被“三年之伤”所取代,当婚后第三十六个月的情感压力达到最高点,夫妻双方如何应对婚姻八面埋伏的挑战:与爱人关系的紧张、微妙的婆媳关系、养不起的孩子、入侵婚姻的彪悍小三……任何一个挑战都足够让婚姻以最快的速度瓦解。 金灿灿、江一朵、杜娟三个80后女孩从不谙世事、懵懂的小女孩逐渐成为妻子、儿媳妇、妈妈。在步入婚姻的第三十六个月,她们经历了很多的困难。在这个过程中,她们不断地改变,不断地适应。经历使她们成长,生活的矛盾与疼痛更让她们炼就了将婚姻的一手烂牌打到最好的勇气。
  • 卓越口才完全修炼

    卓越口才完全修炼

    磁力语言、成功社交、精彩演讲,制胜辩论、“双赢”谈判、温馨情爱、机智应急、日常口才等十个方面的口才技巧。掌握好这些说话技巧,你就能在错综纷繁的人际关系网络中游刃有余;你就能于激烈的社会竞争中脱颖而出;你就能在斗智斗勇的谈判桌上侃侃而谈,屡出奇招。
  • 末日时代

    末日时代

    这是一个崩坏的世界,也是新时代的开启。咒邪的诅咒爆发,早被遗忘的仙魔神也悄然到来……阴谋?战争!在这个时代里,谁能活到最后,在这个时代里,谁能守卫成功……这个时代,名为末日!
  • 极品凤后

    极品凤后

    她本是相府庶女,被大哥卖入宫中,生母来寻,摇身一变成为位高权重的长公主。再次回到宫中,成为皇帝最宠爱的郡主,传说得她者得天下!长姐威胁,她玩弄权术,不屑一顾;太子追求,她装疯卖傻,誓死不嫁;世人嘲弄,她琴棋书画,羡煞旁人!当她遇到了他,她助他夺皇位,帮他守河山,最后他却成为别人的驸马,对她拔剑相向……
  • 前沿:科学发展最高点

    前沿:科学发展最高点

    很久以前的人类是用腿来赶路的,后来马代替了人腿,但是,大概是因为马爱使性子,还必须喂饲料,很麻烦,所以人们萌发了以机器代替马匹的念头。1790年,法国人西哈发明了一辆双轮木马,轮子虽然能转,可是仍然要用两只脚轮流蹬地,使木马前进。这个木马可以说是自行车的雏形。